WEST PIKELAND TWP, PA — West Pikeland Township supervisors voted Monday to proceed with selling the municipal property occupied by SALT Performing Arts, reversing a temporary suspension of the sale and advancing plans to purchase a replacement government facility despite opposition over the financial risks and potential displacement of the community theater, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer.
The board voted 3-2 on Nov. 2 to advertise the property at 1645 Art School Road for bids, without requiring a future buyer to preserve SALT’s existing licensing agreement.
A separate motion to cancel the township’s planned acquisition of 1001 Kimberton Road and halt the sale of its current property also failed 3-2, The Inquirer reported.
Supervisors Steven Costa and Harold M. Hallman III opposed proceeding with the sale and supported rescinding the purchase.
The decisions followed weeks of conflicting board actions, including an October suspension of the sale while officials considered whether the theater could be protected.
The township expects to close on the Kimberton Road property Nov. 13 and has already committed nearly $400,000 in nonrefundable down-payment and due-diligence expenses.
The existing municipal property is scheduled to be advertised for bids Wednesday, Nov. 4.
The transaction would relocate township administrative offices and the police department to the Kimberton Road facility. Proceeds from selling the Art School Road property are intended to help offset the acquisition.
The financial implications remain a central point of contention because the township is proceeding with the purchase before establishing the sale price of its existing property.
SALT Performing Arts, which has operated at the Art School Road location for more than a decade, could also face displacement under the proposed sale terms.
The theater invested approximately $400,000 in improvements to the building in exchange for a 10-year fixed-rent licensing agreement.
Although the proposed bid terms would allow a purchaser to honor that arrangement, they would not require the buyer to maintain SALT’s occupancy.
Township officials have argued that imposing such a requirement could reduce the property’s sale value.
The arrangement has raised questions about the theater’s investment and whether it could recover those expenses if a sale disrupts its occupancy.
“If you go through with this, we’re getting that money back,” SALT President Lauren McComas told supervisors, according to The Inquirer.
The meeting attracted substantial public opposition and continued into early Tuesday morning, marking the third board meeting in recent weeks addressing the property transactions.
Residents questioned the financial assumptions supporting the purchase, including potential renovation costs, borrowing and revenue from future tenants.
“This purchase is just so financially fraught,” resident Meredith Murphy told the board, according to The Inquirer, questioning projections for income from the new facility.
The township has identified the existing police station’s limitations as a principal reason for acquiring the Kimberton Road property.
Supervisor Bryan Maher described the current police facilities as inadequate for the department’s needs, citing a detention area consisting of a bench secured to the floor with attached handcuffs.
Officials envision the replacement property accommodating an expanded police department, administrative operations and potential tenants that could generate rental revenue.
The township also hopes to pursue police accreditation, an objective officials contend is constrained by the existing facilities.
Residents previously approved a tax increase to retain the township’s police department, adding significance to the debate over future policing costs and infrastructure.
Maher also suggested the Kimberton Road location could accommodate community activities, including farmers markets and public events.
Supporters of the purchase argued that the new site would provide more accessible facilities for township employees, police officers and residents.
Resident Regan Sarmento expressed support for relocating the township’s operations to a more visible and accessible property, The Inquirer reported.
Opponents, however, questioned whether the proposed facility would deliver sufficient benefits to justify the financial commitment.
Costa challenged the township’s vision for the property and warned about potential debt associated with the transaction.
“We’re going to have the police department, the admin, and maybe the post office or whatever. That’s not a destination,” Costa told the board, according to The Inquirer. “What we have now in Historic Yellow Springs is a destination.”
Opposition has extended beyond the meetings, with residents collecting hundreds of petition signatures against the purchase.
The board’s latest votes leave the acquisition moving toward its scheduled closing while reopening the sale process for the existing property.
For SALT, the decision removes the temporary pause that had provided an opportunity to reconsider the theater’s position, leaving its continued occupancy dependent on the outcome of the sale and any arrangements with a future owner.
The township’s financial exposure will also depend on the sale proceeds, the costs of adapting the Kimberton Road facility and whether anticipated rental income materializes.
For additional reporting on the supervisors’ votes, the public opposition and SALT Performing Arts’ uncertain future, read Brooke Schultz’s full article in The Philadelphia Inquirer at https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/west-pikeland-salt-performing-arts-20261103.html.
Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.