WEST CHESTER, PA — Chester County school districts and charter schools face further delays in receiving official 2026 standardized test results after Pennsylvania’s State Board of Education rejected proposed scoring changes Thursday, November 19, leaving educators without finalized performance data months into the academic year, according to Chalkbeat Philadelphia.
The board voted 5-9, with one abstention, against a Pennsylvania Department of Education proposal to revise proficiency thresholds for the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment (PSSA) and Keystone exams.
The decision requires the department to process results using the existing scoring system, extending a delay that has already prevented schools from receiving official scores from tests administered last spring.
Approximately 900,000 Pennsylvania students took the assessments, which measure academic performance and contribute to school accountability reporting.
For Chester County, the delay affects all 14 public school districts, along with charter schools, cyber charter schools and schools operated by the Chester County Intermediate Unit.
District administrators remain without finalized results needed to evaluate student achievement, compare school performance and identify instructional priorities. Families also continue waiting for official reports showing how their children performed.
Pennsylvania Department of Education Deputy Secretary Amy Lena confirmed that the agency must now process results under the previous standards.
“We will just have to go back, we’ll have to make sure that we run them under the old (scoring system),” Lena told the board, according to Chalkbeat Philadelphia. “That will take a little bit of time.”
The department did not establish a new release date.
State officials had previously indicated that districts could receive results within days if the proposed scoring changes were approved. The rejection eliminates that timetable.
The disputed proposal would have adjusted the score thresholds used to classify student performance on PSSA English-language arts and mathematics assessments and Algebra I and Literature Keystone exams.
Education officials argued that revised thresholds would improve scoring accuracy and result in more students receiving advanced performance classifications.
However, board members questioned whether the proposed changes had received sufficient scrutiny and whether the 2026 testing cycle provided an appropriate basis for establishing new standards.
The concerns followed Pennsylvania’s transition to mandatory online testing last spring, when districts experienced technical problems during administration.
State Sen. Lindsey Williams, the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, opposed the proposal, questioning the timing of changes following the testing transition.
“I’m not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward,” Williams told the board, according to Chalkbeat Philadelphia.
Williams also criticized the department’s handling of the proposal, citing “communication breakdowns that happened at multiple points in the process.”
Several board members reported learning of the proposed scoring revisions only shortly before the vote, leaving limited opportunity for public review.
House Education Committee Chair Peter Schweyer supported the proposal despite acknowledging concerns about its timing.
The state’s mathematics and reading proficiency thresholds were last revised in 2015, and Schweyer argued that an updated scoring framework was overdue.
“We’ve gone way too long for addressing these (cut scores) in any kind of systematic or thoughtful manner,” Schweyer explained.
The continued delay has practical consequences for schools attempting to use assessment data to guide instruction during the current academic year.
Board Vice Chair Carol Aichele, who supported the proposed changes, questioned the usefulness of results arriving so late.
“The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we’re almost halfway through the current year,” Aichele observed.
The uncertainty has already disrupted school admissions procedures in Philadelphia, where district officials twice postponed application deadlines while awaiting test scores used to determine eligibility for competitive magnet schools.
Philadelphia’s school selection application period is scheduled to close December 16, although officials remain uncertain whether the necessary scores will be available.
While Chester County schools face different local administrative requirements, the statewide reporting delay leaves districts operating without finalized assessment data that would ordinarily have been available before the school year began.
The Department of Education must now complete scoring under the existing standards before releasing official results to districts, schools and families.
For additional reporting on the board’s decision, the disputed scoring proposal and its consequences for Pennsylvania students, read Chalkbeat Philadelphia’s coverage at https://www.chalkbeat.org/philadelphia/2026/11/19/pennsylvania-proposal-to-change-state-test-cut-scores-fails-to-pass/.
Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.
