Lancaster Man Convicted of Strangling Woman Three Times

Court News

LANCASTER, PA — A Lancaster County jury convicted a 33-year-old Lancaster man of strangulation and simple assault on November 17, 2026, following a two-day trial involving allegations that he repeatedly attacked a woman inside his home in September 2024.

Luis Alfonso Betemit was found guilty on all counts after approximately 45 minutes of deliberation, according to the Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office.

Prosecutors said Betemit strangled the then-32-year-old woman three times at his residence in the 500 block of New Dauphin Street in Lancaster.

During the trial, the woman testified that Betemit became upset following an argument with a friend before striking her in the face, throwing her to the ground and placing his hands around her throat, preventing her from breathing.

READ:  Parkesburg Woman Arrested on Strangulation Charges

First Assistant District Attorney Travis Anderson, who prosecuted the case, presented photographs showing bruising on the woman’s neck, face and back as evidence supporting her testimony.

The defense challenged the woman’s account, questioning why she did not immediately leave the residence if she believed she was in danger.

“You be the judge of whether that makes sense to you,” Betemit’s attorney told jurors during closing arguments.

Anderson countered that a victim’s response to an assault does not determine whether the violence occurred or whether the person deserves legal protection.

READ:  West Whiteland Police Arrest Man on Robbery Warrant

“Abusers, predators and people who want to cause harm,” Anderson told jurors, “are good at picking their victims,” who may be afraid to report abuse.

He also argued that the woman “didn’t make up the injuries she claimed,” pointing to the photographic evidence.

The woman testified during the proceedings and became emotional when the jury returned its guilty verdict, according to prosecutors.

Lancaster County Judge Dennis Reinaker, who presided over the trial, will sentence Betemit following completion of a presentence investigation.

READ:  Parkesburg Woman Faces Aggravated Assault, Resisting Arrest Charges

Betemit remains incarcerated at Lancaster County Prison on an unrelated parole violation. According to the District Attorney’s Office, he was on state parole stemming from a previous felony domestic violence case in Lancaster County involving a different victim.

Lancaster City Bureau of Police Officer Nicholas Nolan filed the charges.

Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.