EXTON, PA — A national survey of more than 18,000 substitute teachers found many K-12 districts face persistent gaps in training, classroom support and retention despite relying on an experienced and highly credentialed substitute workforce.
The survey, conducted by Red Rover in partnership with the Substitute Management Council, gathered responses from substitute teachers across 46 states.
Nearly one in four respondents reported receiving no training before entering classrooms, with classroom management and education technology identified as the most needed areas for support.
The findings also showed substitute teachers are often more experienced than districts may assume. Nearly 60% of female respondents were older than 46, and many identified themselves as retired teachers or certified educators. About 30% reported holding graduate or advanced degrees.
At the same time, the survey suggested many substitutes are not pursuing full-time teaching careers. More than 80% of substitutes ages 46 to 61 and more than 95% of those ages 62 to 80 reported no interest in permanent teaching positions.
Instead, respondents in older age groups cited flexibility, supplemental income and community engagement as primary reasons for substitute teaching.
Younger substitutes showed stronger interest in entering the profession permanently. Half of first-year substitutes between ages 18 and 45 reported either pursuing or planning to pursue teacher certification.
Retention trends appeared relatively stable overall, with nearly 75% of respondents indicating plans to continue substitute teaching next year and only 1.4% planning to leave the field entirely.
The survey also identified regional differences in workforce dynamics. Districts in the Northwest reported the youngest substitute pool but the lowest retention rates, while substitutes in the Southwest placed greater emphasis on equitable pay amid economic pressures.
Midwestern districts reported the highest concentration of experienced substitutes, with nearly one-quarter of respondents reporting more than six years of teaching experience.
Dani O’Shaughnessey, chief executive officer and co-founder of Red Rover, said the results pointed to operational changes districts could make to strengthen substitute staffing.
“The results clearly show that by adapting some strategies, K-12 districts can build a stronger, sustainable substitute workforce,” O’Shaughnessey said in a statement.
Jamie West, executive director of the Substitute Management Council, said the findings highlighted the importance of training, flexibility and compensation in retaining substitute educators.
The survey focused on substitute teacher demographics, career goals, training access, compensation perceptions and workforce support systems in K-12 school districts nationwide.
The full survey was published by Red Rover.
Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.