West Whiteland to Appeal Exton Square Mall Redevelopment Ruling

Exton Square Mall food court entrance

EXTON, PA — West Whiteland Township officials intend to appeal a Chester County judge’s Nov. 13 ruling approving the redevelopment of Exton Square Mall, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported, prolonging a legal dispute over a project that would replace the former shopping center with hundreds of homes and new commercial space.

The decision by Chester County Court of Common Pleas Judge Sarah B. Black overturned the township supervisors’ rejection of a redevelopment application submitted by Abrams Realty & Development, the property’s owner.

Black concluded that the developer had presented sufficient evidence to establish that its proposed use of the property was consistent with public health, safety and welfare requirements.

In her ruling, the judge wrote that township supervisors appeared to have held the developer to a “higher standard due to fears of overdevelopment,” according to The Philadelphia Inquirer.

The township’s opposition centers on concerns about traffic, sewer infrastructure and residential density. Supervisors rejected the proposal last fall, prompting Abrams Realty & Development to challenge the decision in court.

READ:  Neighbors Gain Legal Standing in Pennhurst Data Center Appeal

“The township is pursuing all its legal options, and the board intends to appeal the decision,” township supervisors Chair Brian Dunn stated to The Philadelphia Inquirer.

Vice Chair Rajesh Kumbhardare also defended the township’s position.

“I will not hesitate to stand up and fight for our community when I believe a decision does not serve its best interests,” Kumbhardare told the newspaper.

Despite the pending legal challenge, developer Peter Abrams is preparing for demolition of the former mall.

Abrams, chief executive officer of Abrams Realty & Development, informed The Philadelphia Inquirer that demolition could begin by early summer 2027. Bisnow separately reported that demolition and construction could start as early as spring if township permitting proceeds smoothly.

Those schedules remain preliminary, with additional permitting required and the township’s planned appeal leaving the project’s legal status contested.

READ:  Court Ruling Clears Path for Exton Square Mall Redevelopment

The redevelopment would replace much of the nearly 1 million-square-foot shopping center with a mixed-use development combining residential housing, retail, restaurants and recreational facilities.

Plans call for 172 townhouses, 381 apartments and 165 age-restricted apartments, bringing the proposed residential total to 718 units.

The commercial component would include nearly 170,000 square feet of retail, restaurant and related space, along with approximately 120,000 square feet devoted to fitness and entertainment uses.

The developer also envisions medical offices, public green space and connections to existing apartments and the nearby Whole Foods.

Several existing businesses would remain, including the 178,000-square-foot Boscov’s department store, Main Line Health offices and the Round1 entertainment venue.

Abrams Realty & Development, based in Elkins Park, acquired the mall from Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust, or PREIT, for more than $34 million.

Exton Square Mall closed in June after 53 years of operation. Once home to more than 100 stores, the property had experienced years of declining occupancy before its closure.

READ:  Willistown Secures $195,000 for West Chester Pike Signal Upgrade

The redevelopment is part of a broader shift affecting regional shopping centers as property owners seek alternative uses for aging enclosed malls.

Other Philadelphia-area properties facing redevelopment uncertainty include Neshaminy Mall in Bucks County, Franklin Mall in Northeast Philadelphia and the former Echelon Mall in Voorhees, New Jersey.

For Exton Square, the court ruling represents a significant legal victory for the developer, but the township’s intended appeal means the dispute over the property’s future will continue as Abrams pursues the approvals needed to begin construction.

Read the full report from The Philadelphia Inquirer at https://www.inquirer.com/real-estate/commercial/exton-square-mall-redevelopment-town-center-20261116.html.

Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.