EXTON, PA — A Chester County judge has overturned West Whiteland Township’s rejection of the Exton Square Mall redevelopment plan, clearing a major legal obstacle to a proposed mixed-use development that would replace much of the former shopping center with hundreds of homes and new commercial space, according to a recent report by the Philadelphia Business Journal.
The decision reverses the township Board of Supervisors’ October 2025 denial of a master plan submitted by Abrams Realty & Development, ending a central dispute over whether the developer could advance its proposal under the zoning regulations in effect when it applied.
The ruling allows the project, known as The Walk at Exton Town Centre, to move toward detailed land-development review. It does not constitute final construction approval, and additional engineering, infrastructure and permitting requirements remain.
The redevelopment would transform approximately 75 acres at the intersection of Routes 30 and 100, where the enclosed mall concourse closed June 30, 2026, into a district combining residential, retail, office and recreational uses.
West Whiteland Township’s description of the final master plan identified 718 residential units, including apartments and townhouses, along with new retail and office space, restaurants and public gathering areas.
Earlier traffic documentation described 376 apartments and 243 multifamily or townhouse units, totaling 619 residences, and approximately 290,000 square feet of commercial space. The township’s later master-plan description reflects a larger residential component.
Under the revised July 2025 master plan, Boscov’s would remain in its existing building, while Main Line Health would relocate to the ground floor of the former J.C. Penney building, currently occupied by Round1. That building and the eastern parking garage would also be retained.
Boscov’s and Round1/Main Line Health continued operating through exterior entrances after the mall’s interior concourse closed June 30, 2026.
Abrams acquired the mall property from Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust for approximately $34.25 million in March 2025, positioning the developer to pursue one of Chester County’s largest proposed commercial property redevelopments.
The project subsequently became the subject of a zoning dispute after West Whiteland amended its Town Center regulations to reduce permissible residential density and restrict certain housing types.
Abrams maintained that its previously submitted application remained governed by the earlier ordinance, which allowed the higher-density development.
Although the township Planning Commission recommended approval, supervisors rejected the master plan in October 2025.
Their concerns included traffic congestion near Routes 30 and 100, sewer capacity, emergency-service demands, residential density and potential effects on local schools. Officials also questioned whether the proposed commercial component was sufficient.
The developer challenged the rejection in Chester County Court of Common Pleas, arguing that its application satisfied the ordinance’s objective requirements and that supervisors lacked a lawful basis to deny approval.
The case, ARD Exton Square LLC v. Board of Supervisors of West Whiteland Township, was filed under docket number 2025-10318-MJ.
During arguments in April 2026, Judge Sarah B. Black considered competing interpretations of the township’s authority to reject a master plan that met the ordinance’s technical requirements.
Abrams attorney Marc Kaplin argued that the developer had satisfied the applicable standards, relying partly on statements from township Planning Director John Weller.
Township attorney Alex Baumler maintained that supervisors retained authority to evaluate broader consequences, including traffic, infrastructure demands and the effects of residential density.
Black raised the possibility of allowing the proposal to advance with conditions addressing municipal concerns. The subsequent ruling reverses the supervisors’ denial, although the precise requirements imposed by the court depend on the written order.
The dispute also produced separate litigation over the township’s revised zoning regulations.
In July 2026, the West Whiteland Zoning Hearing Board rejected Abrams’ challenge to the residential-density restrictions but sustained its challenge to provisions that prohibited amendments to an approved master plan during the first five years following approval.
The disputed provisions, Sections 325-13.E(5)(d) and (e), effectively imposed a five-year restriction on changes to approved master plans. Both parties appealed portions of the zoning board’s decision, leaving separate zoning questions subject to further proceedings.
The latest Common Pleas ruling substantially changes the redevelopment’s immediate prospects by allowing the original master-plan proposal to advance rather than requiring the developer to submit a smaller project under the revised density restrictions.
The next phase will involve more detailed consideration of roadway improvements, sewer infrastructure, emergency-service capacity and the proposed development’s effects on surrounding properties.
Those reviews will also determine what additional municipal approvals and permits are necessary before demolition and construction can proceed.
The redevelopment represents a significant potential change to Exton’s commercial center, replacing a largely closed enclosed mall with a combination of housing, businesses and public spaces.
The court decision removes a principal legal barrier to that transition while leaving the project’s construction schedule and final development requirements subject to further review.
For additional reporting on the court ruling and its implications for the Exton Square Mall redevelopment, read Paul Schwedelson’s article in the Philadelphia Business Journal at https://www.bizjournals.com/philadelphia/news/2026/11/15/exton-square-mall-redevelopment-approved-appeal.html.
Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.
