West Whiteland Faces Mall Appeal, New Taxes and $1M Road Vote

West Whiteland Township

WEST WHITELAND TWP, PA — West Whiteland Township supervisors face a series of consequential decisions November 24 involving the disputed 718-home Exton Square Mall redevelopment, potential new business taxes, rising sewer and trash collection costs, and a $1 million emergency-access road, setting up a meeting with significant implications for development, municipal finances and public safety in one of Chester County’s major commercial centers.

The Board of Supervisors is scheduled to consider authorizing an appeal of a court decision overturning its rejection of the proposed Exton Square redevelopment. Separately, officials will examine revenue measures intended to address recurring utility fund deficits while pursuing state funding for transportation infrastructure.

The agenda also includes a regional fire and emergency medical services study, repairs to deteriorating sewer infrastructure and an agreement needed to advance improvements at Exton Park.

The meeting begins at 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, November 24.

Exton Square Redevelopment Faces Another Legal Hurdle

Supervisors will consider authorizing an appeal in ARD Exton Square LLC v. Board of Supervisors, docket 2025-10318-MJ, following a ruling by Judge Sarah Black reversing the township’s denial of the proposed redevelopment of Exton Square Mall.

The approximately 75-acre project would replace the existing shopping center with a mixed-use development containing 718 residential units alongside commercial uses.

An appeal could extend the legal dispute and delay the project’s progression toward detailed land-development review, prolonging uncertainty over the future of a major Exton commercial property.

The November 24 agenda lists authorization to appeal as a formal business item. The proposed action does not establish that supervisors have approved an appeal or that one has been filed.

Township Explores New Taxes as Operating Costs Increase

The township is also evaluating additional revenue sources as recurring expenses outpace collections in its sewer and solid waste funds.

A November 20 memorandum from Township Manager Pam Gural-Bear and Finance Director Caroline Partridge identifies financial pressures involving aging infrastructure, rising service costs and limited growth in recurring revenue.

The proposed 2027 General Fund budget totals approximately $17.6 million and recommends no increase in real estate taxes.

However, the sewer and solid waste funds operate separately from the General Fund and are intended to support their expenses through dedicated revenues.

Township staff warned that existing revenue shortfalls cannot be sustained indefinitely through available reserves.

The annual sewer charge currently stands at $285 per equivalent dwelling unit. A February 2026 study by RVE examined sewer rates and tapping fees, while supplemental financial analysis evaluated operating expenses, reserves and potential adjustments.

The township maintains approximately 100 miles of sewer infrastructure and associated pumping stations, creating ongoing maintenance and replacement obligations.

READ:  Pennsylvania Doubles Daily Pittsburgh-New York Train Service

Solid waste expenses increased under a collection contract that took effect in January 2026.

The township raised its annual household collection fee from $89 to $134, while retaining a $2.50 charge per bag. Despite that adjustment, projected collections remain insufficient to cover ongoing program costs.

Supervisors will discuss possible increases and alternative pricing structures, including phased adjustments, sliding scales and tiered rates.

The discussion will also address how to balance affordability, reserve levels and future capital requirements.

Beyond utility fees, township officials are examining business privilege, mercantile and amusement taxes as potential sources of additional General Fund revenue.

Keystone Collections Group, the township’s tax collector, advised that Pennsylvania law generally prohibits municipalities from establishing new gross-receipts-based business privilege or mercantile taxes. A flat-rate business privilege tax may be permissible, subject to further legal review.

As one example, staff identified an ordinance in Blawnox Borough, Allegheny County, imposing a $400 annual flat-rate business privilege tax.

That amount is a comparison from another municipality, not a proposed West Whiteland tax.

Nine Chester County municipalities currently impose business privilege or mercantile taxes, according to the township memorandum. Staff is examining their rates, collections, administrative requirements and effects on businesses.

Officials are also considering whether an amusement tax could generate revenue from entertainment and recreational activities.

Seven Chester County municipalities have amusement taxes, including Easttown, Tredyffrin, New Garden and West Bradford townships.

West Bradford’s tax, adopted in 1999, generally applies a 5% rate to taxable admissions, with reduced effective rates for certain activities.

Golf greens fees and bowling charges are subject to an effective 2% rate, while other taxable admissions and entertainment cover charges generally carry a 5% rate.

Mechanical amusement devices are taxed at 5% of gross receipts, subject to an annual $25-per-device cap.

West Bradford collects approximately $45,000 to $50,000 annually from the tax, with revenue primarily associated with facilities including Broad Run Golf Course and United Sports.

West Whiteland officials are examining the potential tax base, applicable exemptions, collection expenses and effects on local businesses before determining whether similar measures would be appropriate.

No business or amusement tax ordinance is scheduled for adoption November 24. The discussion is intended to guide additional legal and financial research.

Staff expects to return with possible recommendations, including revised utility fee scenarios and preliminary estimates of potential business tax revenue.

$1 Million Road Proposal Targets Emergency Access

Supervisors will also consider authorizing a $1 million grant application to construct a second entrance to Whiteland Crest, a community where residential, commercial, educational and emergency services traffic currently relies on one primary access point.

READ:  Honey Brook Supervisors to Weigh Revised 69-Home Development

The proposed roadway would connect Namar Avenue to Commerce Drive, providing an alternative to the existing entrance at Bartlett Avenue and Route 100, also known as Pottstown Pike.

According to the township’s November 20 project memorandum, Whiteland Crest includes approximately 95 residential units, five businesses, an elementary school and the West Whiteland Fire Company and emergency medical services station.

The existing intersection experiences significant congestion, particularly during the school year, when buses, parents, residents and businesses use the same entrance.

Emergency vehicles also depend on the intersection when responding to calls.

Township officials said a second connection would improve traffic circulation and provide an alternative route if the Bartlett Avenue entrance becomes blocked or inaccessible.

The project carries a preliminary cost estimate of $1 million, including $687,992 for construction, $176,085 for engineering and consulting, and $135,923 for contingencies and potential additional improvements.

The township plans to seek the full amount through the Commonwealth Financing Authority’s Statewide Local Share Assessment program, which distributes gaming-related revenue to eligible public projects.

Township Transportation Fund resources could provide supplemental financing if necessary.

The project would also require an evaluation of traffic conditions at Namar Avenue and Commerce Drive to determine whether a traffic signal or other intersection improvements are warranted.

The proposed resolution would authorize Board Chairman Brian Dunn and Township Manager Gural-Bear to execute the grant documents.

Applications are due November 30 at 11:59 p.m., with funding decisions generally anticipated the following year.

The November 24 vote concerns authorization to apply for funding. It would not constitute a grant award or construction approval.

Regional Fire and EMS Study Advances

Supervisors will consider ratifying the selection of Robb Consulting to conduct a regional fire and emergency medical services strategic planning study through the West Chester Area Council of Governments.

The study will examine existing emergency service operations, financial pressures, future service needs and opportunities for regional cooperation.

The council selected Robb Consulting on November 19 following a competitive process involving five consulting firms. Three finalists were interviewed October 22.

The total study cost is capped at $60,000, with West Whiteland’s contribution limited to $20,000.

The township previously authorized its participation and financial commitment in August. The amount is included in its proposed 2027 budget, and no additional funding authorization is requested.

Robb Consulting anticipates beginning work in January 2027 and completing the study within six to eight months.

The findings are expected to help participating municipalities evaluate emergency service delivery, funding strategies and potential operational changes.

Sewer Infrastructure Repairs Move Toward Bidding

Another agenda item would authorize competitive bidding for replacement of a deteriorating sanitary sewer manhole on Lee Place.

READ:  West Whiteland to Appeal Exton Square Mall Redevelopment Ruling

Township inspections identified separation, settlement and shifting in the structure, raising concerns about underlying infrastructure or subsurface conditions.

A November 18 memorandum from Public Works Operations Manager Edward J. Culp Jr. warned that continued deterioration could contribute to roadway settlement or potential sinkhole formation.

The proposed work includes investigating subsurface conditions, replacing manhole No. 18, repairing and reconnecting the sewer main, managing wastewater flows during construction and restoring the roadway.

The project would also address underground voids or sinkhole conditions discovered during excavation.

Supervisors are being asked to authorize advertising for bids through PennBid, subject to final review of the specifications by the township’s sewer engineer.

Exton Park Improvements Depend on Waterline Agreement

Supervisors will also consider an easement agreement with Chester County to advance the second phase of improvements at Exton Park.

The project includes proposed restrooms, trails, playground facilities, pavilions, parking improvements, signage and an event stage near the park’s existing multiuse fields.

Township officials determined that the original proposed water connection could not provide adequate pressure, requiring a revised waterline route across county property near the Chester Valley Trail.

The agreement would provide the construction and maintenance rights needed to install the utility connection.

The waterline issue delayed the broader park improvements, prompting the township to obtain an extension of its Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources grant through December 31, 2027.

Township staff intends to complete the waterline work before bidding the restroom and associated site improvements.

Work on the utility infrastructure is anticipated to begin during the first quarter of 2027.

Supervisors Face Multiple Decisions November 24

The November 24 meeting brings together several issues with different financial and operational consequences.

The Exton Square appeal authorization could determine whether the township continues its legal challenge to a major redevelopment project. Budget discussions could establish the direction of future household service fees and potential business taxation.

The Whiteland Crest grant application would seek state support for a transportation improvement intended to address congestion and emergency response limitations.

Other actions would advance regional emergency services planning, sewer infrastructure repairs and park improvements.

The township’s next scheduled supervisors meeting is December 9, when final action on the 2027 budget is expected.

Residents can review the November 24 meeting agenda and supporting documents at https://www.westwhiteland.org/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_11242026-1677.

Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.