WEST PIKELAND TWP, PA — West Pikeland Township supervisors unanimously halted plans Monday, October 26, to solicit bids for a municipal property housing SALT Performing Arts, delaying a potential sale while officials examine whether a new owner can be required to honor the theater company’s existing occupancy agreement, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer.
The board rescinded its October 19 vote to advertise a bid package for the property at 1645 Art School Road in Chester Springs, reversing a step toward selling the site to help finance a larger police facility.
The decision followed public opposition to the potential displacement of SALT, which has occupied part of the property since 2014 and invested approximately $400,000 in improvements under a 10-year agreement signed in 2023.
Supervisors are awaiting legal guidance on whether the township can condition a sale on the purchaser maintaining SALT’s license agreement, which provides fixed rent in exchange for the capital improvements.
Supervisor Bryan Maher acknowledged that imposing such a requirement could reduce the property’s sale price, according to The Inquirer.
“When we get that answer, we will announce that publicly here so there’s no lack of understanding of what our legal guidance is and what we can and cannot do,” Maher told meeting attendees.
The dispute places two municipal priorities in conflict: preserving a community theater’s existing occupancy arrangement and generating revenue to support the township’s planned police facility.
West Pikeland wants to acquire a property at 1001 Kimberton Road to provide additional space and improved facilities for its police department. Selling the Art School Road property would help offset the acquisition cost.
The existing property includes the building occupied by SALT and a separate structure housing the township’s police department.
Township officials previously indicated that selling the property was not contemplated when SALT entered its agreement in 2023.
The theater company completed its renovations in 2025 after raising funds for the improvements.
SALT and Historic Yellow Springs, the property’s former owner, were offered rights of first refusal. However, SALT President Lauren McComas previously indicated that the organization could not afford to purchase the property after financing the renovations.
McComas told The Inquirer that SALT was exploring possible acquisition arrangements with Historic Yellow Springs while hoping the township would protect its existing agreement if the property ultimately went to public bidding.
“For the moment, we feel hopeful,” McComas told the newspaper Tuesday. “Largely because the community has really rallied around this.”
The supervisors’ latest action delays the sale but does not cancel it. Further consideration will depend in part on the township solicitor’s determination of what conditions can legally be imposed on a purchaser.
For additional reporting on the township meeting, public response and SALT’s efforts to preserve its theater space, read The Philadelphia Inquirer’s coverage at https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/west-pikeland-theater-salt-20261027.html.
Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.