DEP Expands Bishop Tube Testing After New Contamination Findings

site layout map
Image via Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection

EAST WHITELAND TWP, PA — Pennsylvania environmental regulators are seeking access to approximately two dozen properties near the contaminated Bishop Tube industrial site in Chester County for expanded air testing this winter after groundwater investigations detected unexpectedly high concentrations of carcinogenic chemicals east of the property, according to reporting by The Philadelphia Inquirer.

The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection plans to conduct 24-hour air monitoring at previously tested locations and 14 additional properties along Fahnestock Road, Conestoga Road, Lancaster Avenue and Village Way, where residential neighborhoods border the former industrial facility.

The expanded investigation follows groundwater and surface-water sampling conducted between March and June 2026. A September report found concentrations of carcinogenic chemicals exceeding residential standards at levels higher than anticipated east of the 13.7-acre property on Malin Road in Frazer.

The findings prompted DEP to broaden its investigation beyond the initial residential sampling program, which had not identified a risk at 10 previously tested properties.

“Based upon the data that we just got in that pre-design investigation, we decided on some additional follow-up,” DEP project officer Dustin Armstrong told residents during a November 19 public meeting, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer.

READ:  Pesticide, Mold-Like Growth Flagged at Thorndale Applebee's

The department mailed property-access surveys in early November to arrange the additional monitoring. Armstrong reported that approximately half of the recipients had responded by Thursday’s meeting.

The latest findings introduce additional residential exposure concerns into a cleanup effort already complicated by decades of industrial contamination and a proposed $11.5 million settlement with companies responsible for pollution at the site.

Bishop Tube operated from 1951 until 1999, manufacturing steel tubing. Industrial activity left behind contamination that includes trichloroethylene, or TCE, a solvent associated with cancer risks. DEP records also identify per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, commonly known as PFAS, at the property.

The site is included on Pennsylvania’s Priority List of Hazardous Sites for Remedial Response and has been the subject of a prolonged dispute over cleanup standards and potential residential redevelopment.

The state reached a proposed settlement earlier this year with companies responsible for contamination at Bishop Tube. The approximately $11.5 million agreement would finance remediation and establish funding for additional environmental work.

A $2.5 million reserve is included to address further response measures identified through the investigation, an increasingly significant provision following the discovery of elevated contamination east of the site.

READ:  Chester County Teams Advance in PIAA State Playoffs

The agreement remains subject to approval by a federal judge.

Under its terms, property owner Constitution Drive Partners would serve as the site remediator, using settlement funds to carry out cleanup activities under DEP oversight and approval.

Developer Brian O’Neill, president of Constitution Drive Partners, has owned the property since 2005 and has proposed residential development there.

The remediation would proceed under Pennsylvania’s Act 2 environmental cleanup standards, which establish requirements for addressing contamination at former industrial and commercial properties.

Officials indicated during Thursday’s meeting that cleanup could take several years.

The latest investigation represents a significant development since the settlement proposal was disclosed in March. While the agreement established a potential funding and remediation structure, subsequent environmental sampling has identified additional contamination concerns near surrounding residential properties.

Those findings could influence the scope of cleanup work as regulators continue investigating potential exposure pathways and determining the measures necessary to address contamination beyond the former industrial site.

Residents attending the November 19 meeting also questioned whether the settlement provides sufficient safeguards, particularly because the property owner seeking redevelopment would be responsible for conducting remediation.

READ:  Storybook Characters Bring Christmas Ball to Parkesburg

“The fox should not be in charge of the health and safety of the hens,” resident Debra Mobile told officials, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer. “I want to know how you are going to protect us.”

DEP would retain regulatory oversight and approval authority under the proposed settlement, while the independent investigation and additional residential monitoring would inform subsequent cleanup decisions.

The department’s immediate priority is securing access to properties for the proposed winter air sampling, which would provide additional information about potential exposure conditions near the site.

The federal court must still approve the settlement before its proposed remediation framework can proceed.

For additional reporting on the expanded testing, residents’ concerns and the Bishop Tube cleanup agreement, read the full article by Brooke Schultz in The Philadelphia Inquirer at https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/bishop-tube-east-whiteland-20261120.html.

Support the local news that supports Chester County. MyChesCo delivers reliable, fact-based reporting and essential community resources—free for everyone. If you value that, click here to become a patron today.